|Flyers hate being packed ever-more tightly like sardines in a tin, but that’s where we are today.
In October, American Airlines revealed that it will insert 12 more seats, or two rows, into its economy class on its Boeing 737-800 fleet and an extra nine seats into its Airbus A321s. At the same time, JetBlue said it will cram 12 additional seats into its A320s.
Then just yesterday, The New York Times asked how much farther can airlines push for higher profits by ‘densification’ before causing a backlash?
A legitimate issue around safety
For years the airlines have been allowed to steadily shrink the size of coach class seats without regulators considering the impact of this on safety. But, an investigation by Clive Irving for The Daily Beast has found (a must read link!):
* The tests carried out to ensure that all the passengers can safely exit a cabin in an emergency are dangerously outdated and do not reflect how densely packed coach class seating has become-or how the size of passengers has simultaneously increased;
* No coach class seat meets the Department of Transportation’s own standard for the space required to make a flight attendant’s seat safe in an emergency;
* Neither Boeing nor the Federal Aviation Administration will disclose the evacuation test data for the newest (and most densely seated) versions of the most widely used jet, the Boeing 737.
FlyersRights brought a case that was heard by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, where a judge said there was “a plausible life-and-death safety concern” over the “densification” of seats in economy class.
The court also ordered the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) to respond to our petition about how to deal with safety concerns due to the shrinking seat sizes.
Further, the court criticized the FAA for using outdated studies to argue that no change was needed for emergency evacuation tests.
A Perfect Storm
Meanwhile, at the same time, seat manufacturers are racing to come up with ‘innovative designs’ in densification by shaving down every possible angle to please the airlines – by removing the seatback pocket, replacing padding with mesh and narrowing the armrests. Gone are metal frames with thick cushioning.
The motivation to tighten space between rows of seats is occurring as the US major airlines are opting for 10 across in the Boeing 777s – instead of the previous nine abreast, so the middle section will have two middle seats, instead of one.
“There’s Always An Upgrade To Business Class”
As masters of fine-tuning passengers’ misery into profits, the airlines are quick to say that packing in more seats is ‘necessary’ to keep fares ‘low’, while touting Business class as the alternative. Although, the price difference between Economy and Business is often in the order of several multiples.
The former CEO of Continental Airlines, Gordon Bethune, once said, “It’s the old adage: You can make a pizza so cheap, nobody will eat it. You can make an airline so cheap, nobody will fly it.”
But in reality, few words have more debunked than this.
Update on FlyersRights.org v FAA seat case:
FlyersRights.org has filed Freedom of Information Requests to smoke out exactly when and how the FAA has tested seats for emergency evacuation rule compliance (90 seconds with half the exits disabled in low light conditions. This is required by an airliner in order to provide service to the general public.
Latest revelation– Last time an actual full test was conducted was in 1988! Since then, FAA has accepted “analysis” in lieu of testing as presented by airliner manufacturers.
Sign up for this newsletter